Gerenti Tersirat di Bawah Akta Pelindungan Pengguna 1999: Penambahbaikan kepada Syarat Tersirat di Bawah Akta Jualan Barang 1957?

Zeti Zuryani Zakuan, Sakina Shaik Ahmad Yusoff

Abstract


The present era of globalisation saw the fall of national borders as a result of movement of capital, labor, commodities, ideas, communication, and not forgetting the international goods from overseas into Malaysia. These movements have a big impact in changing the culture and understanding of the law. Trade in Malaysia at present is dominated by sellers. Thus, consumers in Malaysia has now become a group oppressed by an unhealthy trade practices by the more influential sellers. The role of law in the supply of goods can not be denied. Consumer protection laws in Malaysia at present is needed due to the complex and complicated nature of goods supplied by the seller as a result of the sophistication of technological innovation. The problem triggers the enactment of a more comprehensive legislation in order to protect consumers in Malaysia which is the Consumer Protection Act 1999 (CPA 1999). Despite the introduction of CPA 1999 to protect consumers in Malaysia, prior legislation that is the Sale of Goods Act 1957 (SGA 1957) still applies to contracts for the supply of goods. In contract of supply of goods, implied terms are very important to issues relating to trader’s civil liability for goods. The weaknesses of the implied terms under the law of supply of goods have become barriers to claims for breach of contract. Adopting a doctrinal approach, this article analyses the five implied guarantees under the CPA 1999 which are similar to the implied conditions under SGA 1957. The analysis is aimed at assessing whether the guarantees under CPA 1999 have been successfully in overcoming the problems of implied conditions under SGA 1957 in order to protect consumers in the market.

Keywords


implied guarantee, implied terms, consumer, Consumer Protection Act 1999, Sale of Goods Act 1957

Full Text:

PDF

References


Atiyah, P.S. 1985. The Sales of Goods. Edisi ke 7.

London: Longman.

Atiyah, P.S., Adams J.N. & Mac Queen, H. 2005. The

Sale of Goods. Edisi ke 11. London: Longman.

Azmi, S.S.H. 2001. Sale of Goods and Consumer

Protection in India. New Delhi: Deep & Deep

Publications.

Benjamin. 1931. Sales of Personal Property. Edisi ke 7.

London: Sweet & Maxwell.

Benjamin. 1981. Sales of Goods. Edisi ke 2. London:

Sweet & Maxwell.

Benjamin. 1987. Sales of Goods. Edisi ke 3. London:

Sweet & Maxwell.

Carter, J.W. 2010. The Commercial side of Australian

consumer protection law. Journal of Contract Law

: 221.

Department of Justice. 1974. The seller’s responsibilities

in the absence of express statements:Implied terms

as to title, quality and fitness. First Report of the

Consumer Protection Project Consumer Guarantees

in the Sale or Supply of Goods. New Brunswick:

Department of Justice.

Furmston. 1999. The Law of Contract. London:

Butterworths.

Hawes, C. 1992. Consumer law reform: The consumer

guarantees bill. Canterbury Law Review 5 : 26.

Hawes, C. 2007. Consumer Guarantees Act 1993. Dlm

Hawes, C. (pnyt.). Butterworths Introduction to

Commercial Law. Wellington: Lexis Nexis.

Law Commission Working Paper No. 85 on the Sale and

Supply of Goods. 1983.

Naemah Amin. 2002. Guarantees in a contract of supply

of goods to consumers. IIUM Law Journal 10(1) :

Naemah Amin. 2008. The consumer expectation test

under the Malaysian Consumer Protection Act

: A viable test for determining a quality and

safety of products. Proceedings of the 5th Asian Law

Institute Conference, hlm 10.

Rachagan, S.S. 1992. Consumer Law Reform-A Report.

Selangor: University Malaya Press.

Roger Tan Kor Mee. 1990. The need to amend section

and 14 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979. CLJ 2 :

xviii.

Sakina Shaik Ahmad Yusoff. 2001. Akta Jualan Barang-

Barang 1957 lwn. APP 1999: Kearah pemantapan

pelindungan pengguna di Malaysia. Prosiding

Persidangan Kebangsaan Undang-undang

Perniagaan, hlm 50.

Shaik Mohd. Noor Alam S.M. Hussain. 2000. Undangundang

Komersil Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur: Dewan

Bahasa dan Pustaka.

Twigg-Flesner, C. & Bradgate, R. 2002. The E.C.

Directive on certain aspects of the sale of consumer

goods and associated guarantees- All talk and no

do?. Web JCLI 2.

Twigg-Flesner, C. 2002. Dissatisfaction guaranteed?

The legal issues of extended warranties explored.

Web JCLI 2.

Vilmah Balakrishnan. 2006. Quality standards in sale of

goods transaction in Malaysia: A time for reflection.

HELP LR 1 : 46.

Wu Min Aun. 2000. Consumer Protection Act

Supply of Goods And Services. Selangor:

Longman.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.