Reassessing the Legal Status of Gaza in Light of The ICJ’s Recent Palestine Advisory Opinion
Abstract
Israel unilaterally declared in 2005 that they disengaged from Gaza and that the latter was no longer an occupied territory. Since then, the legal status of Gaza has become a contentious issue. The debate has resurfaced due to Israel’s onslaught in Gaza that started after 7 October 2023. The situation has become worse due to a very recent controversial proposal of President Trump to assume control over Gaza and the relocation of its Palestinian residents to neighboring countries, as well as the Israeli military’s plans for an extensive ground invasion to militarily occupy Gaza entirely. The paper is primarily doctrinal legal research, analyzing various interpretations of Article 42 of the Hague Regulations and the recent Palestine Advisory Opinion of the International Court of Justice on effective occupation. The paper finds that the Court rejects the requirement of boots on the ground and affirms the potential control approach, according to which Gaza is still an occupied territory. The Court also reaffirms the self-determination of Palestinians, including the people in Gaza. Despite whatever plans are in the minds of US and Israeli leaders regarding Gaza, Israel is legally bound to respect the right to self-determination of Palestinians and thus the two-state solution.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
REFERENCES
Abdul Ghafur Hamid @ Khin Maung Sein, (2023). Public international law: A practical
approach, (5th edn.) Sweet @ Maxwell, Thompson Reuters.
Arai-Takahashi, Y. (2009). The law of occupation: continuity and change of international
Humanitarian law, and its interaction with international human rights law, Martinus Nijhoff
Publishers.
Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo (Democratic Republic of the Congo v Uganda),
Judgment, ICJ Reports, (2005) 168, Judgment of 19 December 2005.
Aronson, G. (2005). Issues arising from the implementation of Israel’s disengagement from the
Gaza Strip’ Journal of Palestine Studies 34, 49-63.
Benvenisti, E. (2012). The international law of occupation (2nd ed.), Oxford University Press,
-49.
Benvenisti, E. (2015). Occupation and territorial administration, Global Trust Working Paper
/2015, 5-6, http://globaltrust.tau.ac.il/publications.
Chiragov and others v Amenia, European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber, Judgment
(Merits), App no 13216/05, 16 June 2015, para 96.
Convention (IV) respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land and its Annex: Regulations
concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land, the Hague, 18 October 1907 (Hague Regulations).
Cuyckens, Hanne (2016). Is Israel still an occupying power in Gaza? Netherland International
Law Review, 63, 275–295, DOI 10.1007/s40802-016-0070-1
.
Darcy, S. & Reynolds, J. (2010). An enduring occupation: The status of Gaza Strip from the
perspective of international humanitarian law, Journal of Conflict & Security Law 15(2), 211-243.
Dinstein, Y. (2009). The International Law of Belligerent Occupation, Cambridge University
Press.
Dinstein, Y. (2019). The international law of belligerent occupation (2nd edn.), Cambridge
University Press.
Estrin, D., Stern, I., & Baba, (2025). Israel’s latest war plans: To occupy Gaza and rule
Palestinians, NPR News, 24 March 2025, https://www.npr.org/2025/03/24/nx-s1-5337989/israel-gaza-invasion-ham.
Ferraro, T. (2012). Determining the beginning and end of the occupation under international
humanitarian law, International Review of the Red Cross, 94(885) (2012): 133-163, at 150, doi:10.1017/S181638311200063XFerraro.
Flower, K. et. al. (2023). IDF announces expanded ground operation in Gaza, amid
communications blackout in the enclave. CNN News, Sat, October 28, 2023, https://edition.cnn.com/2023/10/27/middleeast/israel-gaza-ground-operations-airstrike-intl/index.html.
Frankel, Julia (2024). With Gaza’s death toll over 40,000, here’s the conflict by numbers.
Associated Press (AP), World News, 16 August 2024, https://apnews.com/article/israel-hamas-gaza-war-palestinians-statistics-40000-7ebec13101f6d08fe10cedbf5e172dde
Gaber Al-Bassiouni v. Prime Minister, HCJ, Case No 9132/07 (Judgment of 30 Jan. 2008), para
Gaza disengagement plan: Knesset approves disengagement implementation law (2005).
Jerusalem Post, 16 February 2005, https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/knesset-approves-disengagement-implementation-law-february-2005#google_vignette.
Gross, A. (2012). Rethinking occupation: a functional approach,’ Opinio Juris, Symposium on
the Functional Approach to the Law of Occupation, 23 April 2012, https://opiniojuris.org/2012/04/23/rethinking-occupation-the-functional-approach/.
Harvery, Lex (2025). Key takeaways from Trump’s plan to ‘take over’ Gaza,’ CNN News, 6
February 2025, https://edition.cnn.com/2025/02/05/middleeast/takeaways-trump-gaza-proposal-intl-hnk/index.html.
Human Rights Watch, (2004). Israel: “Disengagement” will not end Gaza occupation, 28 October
, https://www.hrw.org/news/2004/10/28/israel-disengagement-will-not-end-gaza-occupation.
ICRC updated commentary to Article 2(2) of the Geneva Convention IV (2016).
ICRC, Commentary on first Geneva Convention, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016).
ICRC (2024). What does the law say about the responsibilities of the Occupying Power in the
occupied Palestinian territory? https://www.icrc.org/en/document/ihl-occupying-power-responsibilities-occupied-palestinian-territories.
Israel’s Disengagement from Gaza 2005, Encyclopedia Britannica, last updated 20 August 2024,
https://www.britannica.com/event/Israels-disengagement-from-Gaza.
Jaber, S.S. & Bantekas, I. (2023). The status of Gaza as occupied territory under international law,
International and Comparative law Quarterly 72(4), 1069-1088.
Karni, D., Lister, T. & Nadeen Ebrahim, Israel approves controversial proposal to facilitate
emigration of Palestinians from Gaza, CNN News, 24 March 2025,
https://edition.cnn.com/2025/03/24/middleeast/israel-approves-proposal-to-facilitate-emigration-of-palestinians-from-gaza-intl/index.html.
Krever, Mick (2025). Israel has resumed the war in Gaza. Why now? CNN News, 19 March
, Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, ICJ Advisory Opinion, 19 July 2024.
Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, ICJ,
Advisory Opinion, 9 July 2004.
Lidman, Melanie (2025). What to know about the ceasefire between Israel and Hamas,’ AP News,
January 2025, https://apnews.com/article/israel-gaza-hamas-war-ceasefire-hostages-qatar-prisoners-c707fef6191db7223a6d313a12c46d41.
Lieblich, E. (2017). The normative and functional approaches to occupation: a response to Aeyal
Gross, Opinio Juris, Symposium on Occupation Law, 29 August 2017, https://opiniojuris.org/2017/08/29/the-normative-and-functional-approaches-to-occupation-a-response-to-aeyal-gross/.
Meier, M.W. (2023). The question of whether Gaza is occupied territory,’ Israel – Hamas
Symposium, 15 December 2023, https://lieber.westpoint.edu/question-whether-gaza-occupied-territory/.
Milanovic, M. (2024). The occupation of Gaza in the ICJ Palestine Advisory Opinion,’ EJIL Talk!,
July 23, 2024, https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-occupation-of-gaza-in-the-icj-palestine-advisory-opinion/.
Origin and History of the Conflict between Israel and Palestine, World History Edu, 29 February
, Online at: https://worldhistoryedu.com/origin-and-history-of-the-conflict-between-israel-and-palestine/, accessed 12 September 2024.
Parti, Tarni (2023). Biden opposes ‘reoccupation’ of Gaza by Israeli forces, U.S. spokesman
Says. The Wall Street Journal, November 8, 2023, https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/israel-hamas-war-gaza-strip-2023-11-06/card/biden-opposes-reoccupation-of-gaza-by-israeli-forces-u-s-spokesman-says-mHTt8P9wNeeEr8Oi0BLR.
Prosecutor v M. Naletilic´ and V Martinovic´, ICTY Judgment, Case No IT-98-34-T, Trial
Chamber, 31 March 2003, paras 215–216.
Report of the detailed findings of the Independent Commission of Inquiry established pursuant to
Human Rights Council Resolution S-21/1”, UN doc A/HRC/29/CRP.4 (24 June 2015),
para 29.
Report of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian
Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel, UN doc A/77/328 (14 September 2022) para
Report of the Special Rapporteur John Dugard on the Situation of Human Rights in the
Palestinian Occupied Territories since 1967, (2008). 21 January 2008, UN Doc
A/HRC/7/17, para 11.
Resolution of the General Assembly relating to ‘Israeli practices affecting the human rights of
the Palestinian people in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem’ adopted on 30 December 2022, GA Res 77/247, A/RES/77/247, para 18.
Samson, E. (2010). Is Gaza occupied?: Redefining the status of Gaza under international law,
American University International Law Review, 25(5), 915-967.
Sanger, A. (2011). The contemporary law of blockade and the Gaza Freedom Flotilla’ in Schmitt,
M.N., Arimatsu, L. & Tim McCormack, T. (eds) Yearbook of International Humanitarian
Law, Vol 13, 397.
Sargsyan v Azerbaijan, European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber, Judgment (Merits),
App no 40167/06, 16 June 2015, paras 93ff, 143f.
Schmitt, M.N. (2023). Israel-Hamas 2023 symposium - The legal context of operations Al-Aqsa
flood and swords of iron, Articles of War, Lieber Institute, West Point, 10 October 2023, https://lieber.westpoint.edu/legal-context-operations-al-aqsa-flood-swords-of-iron/.
Security Council Resolution 242, 22 November 1967, S/RES/242(1967).
Separate Opinion of Judge Iwasawa, Palestine Advisory Opinion, 2024.
Separate Opinion of Judge Kooijmans, Armed Activities case, 2005.
Shany, Y. (2005). Far away, so close: The legal status of Gaza after Israel’s disengagement,
Yearbook of International Humanitarian Law, vol 8, 374, https://ssrn.com/abstract=923151.
Trial of Wilhelm List and Others (The Hostages Trial), United States Military Tribunal,
Nuremberg, 1949 United Nations War Crimes Commission, VIII Law Reports of Trials of Major War Criminals, vol VIII, No 47 (1949) 56.
Tsemel v Minister of Defence, HCJ 102/82, 37(3) PD 365.
UK Ministry of Defence, The Manual of the Law of Armed Conflict, Ch 11 (2004) para 11.3.
Office of Judge Advocate General (Canada), Joint Doctrine Manual: Law of Armed Conflict at the Operational and Tactical Level (2001) paras 1202-1203.
United States Department of the Army, Field Manual 27-10, The Law of Land Warfare, 18 July
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, 1969, Article 31(1).
Yunus Emre Gül, (2021). Is the requirement of “boots on the ground” necessary anymore for an
occupation? IBAD Journal of Social Sciences 9, 336-346, DOI: 10.21733/
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.