Reviving the Sultanate of Sulu Through its Claim over Sabah, 1962-1986 (Menghidupkan Semula Institusi Kesultanan Sulu Melalui Tuntutan ke atas Sabah, 1962-1986)

Norizan Kadir, Suffian Mansor

Abstract


The aftermath of colonialism marked the end of a long-standing and glorious Sultanate of Sulu when it finally lost its power and supremacy under the newly-independent Philippines government. Even after the Philippines finally achieved its independence in 1946, the Sultanate of Sulu again failed to revive its old “kerajaan” as it had been abolished by the Philippines government in 1937. As the sultans and his followers had the historical experience regarding the idea of “kesultanan” and other socio-political concepts, the newly-introduced concept namely the nation-state whereby the idea of the boundary and a new nation was created making the traditional sultanate in desperation to sustain their sovereignty and power. The desperation to re-establish and revive their old glorious “kerajaan” eventually turned into a struggle and rigorous attempts to claim Sabah. Hence, this article aims to illustrate the survival of the Sultanate of Sulu after the death of the last sultan in 1936 and the efforts taken to preserve the sultanate within the modern nation-state system. The method of research used in this study involved library and archival research to obtain primary and secondary sources. Among the primary sources consulted in the study include British records, agreements, correspondence, newspapers, government gazettes, memoranda, speeches, and government official publications. Thus, this article lucidly concludes that various trends and approaches taken by the Sultan of Sulu and his heirs to claim Sabah were a part of their mission to sustain and revive the Sultanate of Sulu.

Keywords: Sultanate of Sulu; Philippines government; Sabah and nation-state; sovereignty.

 

Abstrak

Impak kolonialisme telah menyebabkan sebuah kerajaan yang begitu lama bertahan dan gemilang iaitu Kesultanan Sulu akhirnya kehilangan kuasa dan ketuanan di bawah pemerintahan baru yang merdeka iaitu Republik Filipina. Walaupun selepas Filipina mencapai kemerdekaannya pada tahun 1946, Kesultanan Sulu masih gagal untuk menghidupkan semula kerajaannya apabila institusi Kesultanan Sulu dihapuskan oleh Filipina pada tahun 1937. Oleh kerana Sultan Sulu dan pengikutnya itu telah merasai pengalaman memiliki "kesultanan" sendiri serta konsep-konsep sosiopolitik lain, konsep negara bangsa yang baru diperkenalkan yang mengandungi konsep sempadan tertentu dan pembinaan bangsa baru telah menyebabkan Kesultanan Sulu berada dalam keadaan tertekan untuk mempertahankan kedaulatan dan kuasanya. Terdesak untuk memulihkan semula kegemilangan kerajaan lamanya, Sultan Sulu dan pengikutnya akhirnya mula menumpukan kepada perjuangan untuk menuntut Borneo Utara (Sabah). Oleh itu, artikel ini bertujuan untuk menjelaskan kewujudan Kesultanan Sulu selepas kematian Sultan Sulu yang terakhir pada tahun 1936 dan usaha-usaha yang dilakukan bagi mengekalkan kesultanan dalam sistem negara bangsa moden. Kaedah penyelidikan berbentuk kepustakaan telah dilaksanakan bagi mendapatkan data-data daripada sumber primer dan sekunder. Antara sumber primer yang dirujuk dalam kajian ini termasuklah rekod-rekod British, dokumen perjanjian, surat-menyurat, keratan akhbar, warta kerajaan, memorandum, teks ucapan serta terbitan rasmi kerajaan. Kesimpulannya, pelbagai trend dan pendekatan yang diambil oleh Sultan Sulu dan waris-warisnya untuk menuntut Sabah adalah sebahagian daripada misi mereka untuk mempertahankan dan menghidupkan kembali institusi Kesultanan Sulu.

Kata kunci: Kesultanan Sulu; kerajaan Filipina; Sabah dan negara bangsa; kedaulatan.


Full Text:

PDF

References


Abdul Gani Patail. 2013. Putting to Rest: the Claim on Sabah by the Self-Proclaimed Sultanate of Sulu. Kuala Lumpur: Institut Terjemahan Buku Malaysia (ITBM).

Abhoud Syed M. Lingga. 2004. Muslim Minority in Philippines. Paper presented at SEACSN Conference 2004: Issues and Challenges for Peace and Conflict Resolution in Southeast Asia, 12-15 January, Pulau Pinang.

CO 874/942, Sulu Sultanate and Claims for Cession Money. The National Archive.

Dizon, J. S. 1978. The Foreign Policy of the Philippines with Special Emphasis on the Macapagal Administration 1961-1965. Washington, United States of America: The American University.

DO 169/127, Sultan of Sulu’s Heirs Claim on North Borneo. The National Archive.

FCO 15/303, Philippines: Political Affairs (Bilateral), Malaysia. The National Archive.

FO 371/175334, Philippines Proposal to Send A Trade Mission to Sabah. The National Archive.

Ghazali Shafie. 2015. Memoir Ghazali Shafie: Penubuhan Malaysia. Bangi: Penerbit Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.

Harrisson, T. 1966. The Unpublished Rennel Manuscript: A Borneo Philippine Journal, 1762-63. Journal of the Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society, XXXIX-1: 92-136.

Low, H. 1998. Selesilah of the Rajas of Brunei. In Papers Relating to Brunei, edited by Cheah Boon Kheng. Singapore: MBRAS.

Leifer, M. 1968. The Philippine Claim on Sabah. Yorkshire, England: University of Hull.

Majul, C. A. 1988. Islam di Filipina. Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.

Mohd. Samsudin. 2016. Persekutuan Malaysia 1961-1966: Penubuhan dan Cabaran. Bangi: Penerbit Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.

Nik Anuar Nik Mahmud. 2009. Tuntutan Filipina ke atas Borneo Utara. Bangi: Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.

Nisperos, N. M. 1977. Philippine Foreign Policy on the North Borneo Question. Ann Arbor: Xerox University Microfilms.

Norizan Kadir & Wong Tze-Ken, D. 2016. Kempen dan Propaganda Akhbar Tempatan Filipina terhadap Isu Tuntutan Filipina ke atas Borneo Utara, 1961-1963. Jurnal Sejarah 25 (1): 81-92.

Norizan Kadir & Suffian Mansor. 2014. Pengguguran Tuntutan Filipina ke atas Sabah dan Gerakan Pemisahan Sabah pada Dekad Kedua Kepimpinan Ferdinand Marcos, 1977-1980. Jurnal Sejarah 23 (2): 139-156.

North Borneo News and Sabah Times. 1962. The Philippines Claim on North Borneo, 7 September.

Pacific Settlement of Disputes Based on International Law, Malaysia’s Experiences at the International Court of Justice, Occasional Paper, No. 1/2008. 2008. Kuala Lumpur: Institute of Diplomacy and Foreign Relations (IDFR).

Phelan, J. L. 1967. The Hispanization of the Philippines. London: University of Wisconsin Press.

Philippines Claim to North Borneo. The Chronicle. July 1963.

Philippines Claims to North Borneo, Vol. I. 1963. Manila: Bureau of Printing.

Philippines Claims to North Borneo, Vol. II. 1967. Manila: Bureau of Printing.

Republic of the Philippines. 1968. The Facts about Sabah. Manila: National Media Production Center.

Rosario, E. D. 1962. Off the Beat. The Manila Chronicle. 14 & 19 April.

Salman, M. 2001. The Embarrassment of Slavery. California: University of California Press.

Sururul-Ain Ututalum & Abdul-Karim Hedjazi. 2003. The Genealogy of the Sulu Royal Families. Chapel Hill, United States of America: Professional Press.

T 317/503, Financial Settlement of Claim on North Borneo by Heirs of Sulu and Philippine Government. The National Archive.

Tillah, S. C. 2010. On Sulu’s Claim on British North Borneo. The Philippine Law Journal, 26 (3): 199-210.

The Facts About Sabah. 1968. Manila: National Media Production Center.

Ueda, T. 2006. Pembinaan dan Perkembangan Konsep Native di Borneo Utara pada Zaman Kolonial. Akademika 68 (1): 65-89.

Wong Tze-Ken, D. 2015. The Name of Sabah and the Sustaining of a New Identity in a New Nation. Archipel 89: 161-178.

The San Francisco Call. 1907. What Christianity Has Done for the Philippines. 25 August 1907.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN: 0126-5008

eISSN: 0126-8694